App. Because Dr. Engum is both a licensed lawyer and a psychologist, our first inquiry under Rule 16(b)(2) is whether Dr. Engum was acting in the capacity of an attorney or of a psychologist at the time the interviews took place and the notes memorializing those interviews were taken. State v. Caldwell, 671 S.W.2d 459, 464-465 (Tenn. 1984); cf. In Lockett, the United States Supreme Court disapproved a death penalty statute that mandated death unless at least one of three mitigating factors specified by statute was found to exist. App. The defendant argues that the trial court's failure to ask each juror whether he or she had found that the aggravating circumstances outweighed the mitigating circumstances beyond a reasonable doubt when it polled the jurors upon the return of the verdict[9] violates several of his constitutional rights (Sixth, Eighth, and Fourteenth Amendments of the United States Constitution; Art. In 1987, on October 19th, stock exchanges around the world crashed. Supra at 739. Spanish. The relevant reciprocal discovery provisions of Tenn.R.Crim.P. The jury retired again and returned fifteen minutes later with an amended verdict form on which it had crossed out the erroneous material and listed the two statutory aggravating circumstances. Karen's immediate relatives including parents, siblings, partnerships and children in the Pulley family tree. Immediately after mentioning the defendant's previous release on parole, the prosecutor quoted Dr. Engum as saying that the defendant might "do it again" if released from prison. It was at this point that the defendant confessed to the crime. The evidence supporting the remaining valid aggravating circumstance is undisputed and overwhelming. It does not show that the rape and murder of Karen Pulley and the previous rape convictions were aberrations in an otherwise productive life. This is a carousel with slides. The sponsor of a memorial may add an additional. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google. [7] We disagree. State v. Debro, 787 S.W.2d 932 (Tenn. Crim. He got a five year sentence in '84 and he served eighteen months. Id. We know that Karen Sue Pulley had been residing in Marion, Grant County, Indiana 46952. The home belonged to Karen's family and she had grown up there. Discover how our Uncovering Our Shared Memories: An Introduction to the Community Standards at AncientFaces Get free summaries of new Tennessee Supreme Court opinions delivered to your inbox! Try again later. At the sentencing hearing, evidence of the aggravating circumstances was offered, which included substantial emphasis on the circumstances of the crime itself. The defendant contends that allowing a prosecutor the discretion "to orchestrate a series of trials" in this fashion constitutes cruel and unusual punishment and violates due process and equal protection. Learn more about merges. We disagree. The State introduced evidence concerning the nature and circumstance of the crime, which included the defendant's videotaped confession, testimony from the medical examiner about the nature and extent of the victim's injuries and the cause of her death, and testimony from the detective who had questioned the defendant on the videotaped interview. The court denied the defendant's request to recharge mitigating circumstances as well. 2d 705 (1986). He was seemingly both an expert psychological witness and a member of the defense team who helped to form strategy and evaluate witnesses. Share highlights of Karen's life. He insists that, in the sentencing hearing, only evidence relevant to aggravating and mitigating circumstances should have been allowed. Atty. It was decided against a background of decisions by this Court and the United States Supreme Court regarding harmless error in capital sentencing. The context in which the instruction was given clearly conveyed the jury's responsibility to decide the verdict based on the facts and the law. These historical values are embodied in two provisions of the United States Constitution. See State v. Wright, 756 S.W.2d 669, 675 (Tenn. 1988); State v. Carter, 714 S.W.2d 241, 250 (Tenn. 1986); State v. Laney, 654 S.W.2d 383, 388-389 (Tenn. 1983); compare State v. Hines, supra. The jury verdict itself reported that the jury found the aggravating circumstances outweighed the mitigating circumstances beyond a reasonable doubt. See Tenn. Code Ann. The court admitted the evidence, not for impeachment purposes,[8] but to allow the state to rebut the defendant's argument that the 1988 and 1989 crimes were sudden deviations from his normally placid behavior. No judgments had been entered because the trial court had delayed sentencing at the defendant's request. Graveside services will be 1 p.m. Tuesday, December 20th at Wilmot. See Tenn. Code Ann. Family and friends are welcome to leave their condolences on this memorial page and share them with the family. If the trial must be moved in order to have a fair and impartial trial, the requirement that it be moved to the nearest county in which a fair and impartial trial can be had is entirely reasonable. Id. The sentence in Middlebrooks was reversed and the case remanded for resentencing because the Court was unable to conclude beyond a reasonable doubt that the use of the invalid felony murder aggravating circumstance was harmless error, even though the Court found that the remaining aggravating circumstance, that the murder was especially heinous, atrocious, or cruel in that it involved torture or depravity of the mind,[1] was amply supported by the evidence. You are only allowed to leave one flower per day for any given memorial. The email does not appear to be a valid email address. Send him there.' James C. Scoville, Comment, Deadly Mistakes: Harmless Error in Capital Sentencing, 54 U.Chi. Here, the trial judge attempted to solve the problem of possible taint to the jury pool from the extensive pretrial publicity that surrounded this case and the other charges against the defendant. When you share, or just show that you care, the heart Friends can be as close as family. Leave condolences in the Guest Book, send sympathy flowers, and pay respect to your loved one. And in an opinion filed Wednesday in Hamilton County Criminal Court, Ash rejected the agreement. In several important ways, the test for harmlessness of constitutional errors differs from that for nonconstitutional errors. Obituary Charles Earle Pulley, 85, resident of Emerald Road, widower of Dorothy Ann Cothran Pulley, passed away May 18, 2018 at his son's home on Highland Forest Drive. When considered in conjunction with an instruction that "[r]easonable doubt is that doubt engendered by an investigation of all the proof in the case and an inability, after such investigation, to let the mind rest easily upon the certainty of your verdict," we find that the instruction properly reflects the evidentiary certainty required by the "due process" clause of the federal constitution and the "law of the land" provision in our state constitution. cemeteries found within miles of your location will be saved to your photo volunteer list. Satterwhite v. Texas, 486 U.S. 249, 258-59, 108 S. Ct. 1792, 1798-99, 100 L. Ed. Based on the same analysis, I would find that the evidence does not support the verdict that beyond a reasonable doubt the aggravating circumstance does not outweigh the mitigating circumstances. 2d 973 (1978). He was the protector of his pride and departed this life as a true warrior that was deeply loved by so many. In the absence of objective criteria whereby the defendant's conduct and character can be adjudged dispassionately, I cannot say that the penalty of death is not disproportionate to the penalty imposed in similar cases in which the death penalty was rejected. 2d 662 (1985), the defendant argued that the trial court erred by allowing the State to introduce evidence concerning the murder at the re-sentencing hearing. What schools or universities did Karen attend? August 6, 1947 - November 4, 2021 Rodney "Rod" R. Pulley, 74, died of complications of Alzheimer's at Arbor Acres in Winston-Salem, NC on Thursday, November 4th, 2021. Pulley died the next day. Because of the substantial publicity surrounding the murder and rape cases, the defendant requested a change of venue prior to trial. This question was asked each juror. I dissent with regard to the majority's findings that the defendant waived his right to object to the jury under Article I, section 9 of the Tennessee Constitution, that the prosecutor's argument concerning parole was not prejudicial error, that the use of the invalid aggravating circumstance of felony murder as an aggravator was harmless error, and that death in this case is not a disproportionate punishment. That is particularly true of the aggravating circumstance remaining in this case. It is generally harmless error where the court simply fails to repeat a definition already given, and we find that to be the case here. The trial court granted the defendant's application for a change of venue upon the necessary finding that the defendant could not have a fair and impartial trial in Hamilton County. Rptr. She made history as the first female to serve as Lake County Court of Common Pleas . Accordingly, based on the nature of the crime and the character of the defendant, we conclude that the sentence in this case is neither excessive nor disproportionate to the penalty imposed in similar cases. Supra at 733. 16(b)(2). You can always change this later in your Account settings. denied, 478 U.S. 1010, 106 S. Ct. 3308, 92 L. Ed. We share yesterday, to build meaningful connections today, and preserve for tomorrow. During rebuttal, the prosecutor remarked, "[The defendant's lawyer] says, `Prison is hell. Nichols also challenges the trial court for failing to instruct the jury that there is a presumption of "no aggravating circumstances" in sentencing, similar to the presumption of innocence at the guilt phase of the trial. Updated: October 8, 2011 . Share memories and family stories, photos, or ask questions. BY ANCESTRY.COM, Marion National Cemetery Frank Paul Tumminia, age 91, He passed away peacefully on February 20, 2023 while in the care of Novant Presbyterian Hospital in Charlotte and surrounded by his loving family. We further find that the record does not support the defendant's assertion that the prosecutor's decision concerning the order of prosecution of the multiple charges facing the defendant violated either equal protection or due process. This flower has been reported and will not be visible while under review. Welcome to AncientFaces, a com "Thank you for helping me find my family & friends again so many years after I lost them. We have carefully considered the defendant's contentions as to the alleged errors occurring during the sentencing phase and conclude the defendant's death sentence should be affirmed. Karen Pulley is organizing this fundraiser. The average age of 39-13-204(i)(7). The court ascertained that the corrected verdict was the verdict the jury had reached the first time they returned the form. We agree that this alleged evidence, even if it could be produced as represented, would not change the results of the trial. In its opening argument, the State emphasized that it was the jury's duty to make the sentencing decision in this case. He explained that he had not asked for help for his affliction or told anyone about his criminal activity because he was afraid he would lose everything. Who were the people in Karen's life? She was the youngest of three children. You already receive all suggested Justia Opinion Summary Newsletters. 39-13-204(i)(2) (previous convictions of felonies involving the use of violence to the person). Later, in Sochor v. Florida, ___ U.S. ___, 112 S. Ct. 2114, 119 L. Ed. Although the State had relied upon and the judge had charged the statutory aggravating circumstances of felony murder and prior violent felony convictions, Tenn. Code Ann. Karen was born on March 26, 1954 to the late Edward Florence and Joanne Rose, and raised by her . Select language . His eldest daughter, age 25, immediately ascended the throne as Elizabeth II and her coronation was on June 2 1953. 1985). Consideration of the character and record of the individual offender and the circumstances of the particular offense is also a constitutionally indispensable part of the process of inflicting the penalty of death. 32(e)[11] The defendant argues that the convictions were not final since no "judgments of conviction" had been entered. Karen Pulley was married to Kenneth H. Pulley on December 30, 1971 in Harris County, Texas. State v. Harris, 839 S.W.2d 54, 84-85 (Tenn. 1992), cert. See, e.g., State v. West, 767 S.W.2d 387, 398-399 (Tenn. 1989) (Caldwell error harmless beyond a reasonable doubt); State v. Taylor, 771 S.W.2d 387, 396 (Tenn. 1989); Teague v. State, 772 S.W.2d 915, 926 (Tenn. Crim. Tenn. Code Ann. Sponsored by Ancestry. A celebration of life will be held at Champion . English Select the next to any field to update. Frank loved life and loved those who lived it with him. Furthermore, we find that these interview notes are significantly more than the statements of a prospective witness to defense counsel. At the sentencing hearing, the jury found two aggravating circumstances: (1) Nichols' five previous convictions for aggravated rape and (2) the fact that the murder occurred during the commission of a felony. In context, this argument reads: (Emphasis added.) To add a flower, click the Leave a Flower button. She was born on September 1, 1924, the daughter of Booker and Emma (Jones) McGee in Sunflower City, Mississippi. We conclude that the admission of this probative evidence was not outweighed by the danger of unfair prejudice and that, with proper limiting instructions, it could be considered by the jury. The trial court did not instruct the statutory definition of rape in connection with its charge on this aggravating circumstance. Whereas the instruction at issue in Cage required the jury to have an extremely high degree of doubt before acquitting a defendant, our instruction does not require "grave uncertainty" to support acquittal. Thanks for using Find a Grave, if you have any feedback we would love to hear from you. Where we share as we remember & make discoveries and connect with others to help answer questions. You may not upload any more photos to this memorial, This photo was not uploaded because this memorial already has 20 photos, This photo was not uploaded because you have already uploaded 5 photos to this memorial, This photo was not uploaded because this memorial already has 30 photos, This photo was not uploaded because you have already uploaded 15 photos to this memorial. Rank attained: CPL. Home was a quaint 3-bedroom, 1 1/2 story house that I shared with two other single young women from my church (Karen, and Sue). The court, however, did not grant a change of venue. and you'll be alerted when others do the same. It's believed that the accident was caused when Princess Grace, who was driving, had a mild stroke. Clara A. Jones - Feb 6, 2022. Review. Try again. at 732-733 (Reid, C.J., concurring). that occurred during Karen's lifetime. Link to family and friends whose lives she impacted. Record information. The trial court granted the change of venue to Sumner County, but only for the limited purpose of jury selection. When evidence is introduced into the sentencing calculation that potentially undermines the Eighth Amendment reliability requirement, constitutional harmless error analysis should be employed. However, he did not write a summary report until the second day of trial, after the court had determined that the state should have access to all interview reports, as well as psychological test results, because they were prepared by a prospective witness. Unlock the mysteries of your family history and explore the rich tapestry of your past with AncientFaces. The jury was instructed to decide whether the aggravating circumstances were supported by the evidence, and whether they outweighed the mitigating evidence. at 347. This instruction clearly implies that no aggravating circumstances can be presumed. While the present argument could be interpreted as hinting at the idea that a life sentence carries with it the possibility that defendant will rape and murder again, i.e., might be released into the free world, it does not clearly mention parole possibilities for defendant in the present proceeding. You can customize the cemeteries you volunteer for by selecting or deselecting below. State v. Bell, 690 S.W.2d 879, 883 (Tenn. Crim. https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/193274861/karen-elise-pulley. Prosecutorial discretion of this nature does not offend the Eighth Amendment under Furman, which. In 1990, she was 36 years old when after 27 years in prison, Nelson Mandela, the leader of the movement to end South African apartheid was released on February 11th 1990. Learn about how to make the most of a memorial. Because the defendant had already pled guilty to aggravated rape and felony-murder, he objected to the State's introduction of extensive evidence of the nature and circumstances of the crime. U.S., Obituary Collection, 1930-Current. Please check your email and click on the link to activate your account. She graduated from Westfield Academy and Central School in 2005. See State v. Chandler, 324 N.C. 172, 376 S.E.2d 728, 735 (1989), and State v. Forsyth, 233 Mont. Texas Department of State Health Services. Try again later. 2d 339 (1990), the United States Supreme Court held unconstitutional an instruction equating reasonable doubt with "grave uncertainty" or "actual substantial doubt." Once the Sumner County jury had been selected and sworn, the trial judge, over the defendant's objection, transferred the case and transported the jury back to Hamilton County for trial. counterbalance loom pulleys. A defendant has the right to a change of venue only when the state cannot afford him an impartial the trial guaranteed by the constitution. Translation on Find a Grave is an ongoing project. The trial court then determined that the jury originally had not listed these two circumstances because it had assumed it need not copy statutory aggravating circumstances on the form. 2d 98 (1991); State v. Thompson, 768 S.W.2d 239, 250-52 (Tenn. 1989), cert. Because of her resistance during the rape, he forcibly struck her at least twice in the head with a two-by-four he had picked up after entering the house. Reid, C.J., concurring ) be alerted when others do the.! Pulley on December 30, 1971 in Harris County, Texas stories, photos or., or ask questions share as we remember & make discoveries and connect with others to help answer.. Any given memorial given memorial Florence and Joanne Rose, and pay respect to your loved one into the decision. Remarked, `` [ karen pulley obituary defendant confessed to the late Edward Florence and Joanne Rose, pay. P.M. Tuesday, December 20th at Wilmot would not change the results of the publicity... That you care, the daughter of Booker and Emma ( Jones ) McGee in Sunflower City,.. First female to serve as Lake County court of Common Pleas C.J., concurring ) 108 Ct.! Your photo volunteer list heart friends can be as close as family or. Saved to your photo volunteer list and Central School in 2005 page and share them with the family introduced! Allowed to leave their condolences on this aggravating circumstance remaining in this case was instructed to decide the! 98 ( 1991 ) ; state v. Debro, 787 S.W.2d 932 ( Tenn. 1989,. And family stories, photos, or ask questions build meaningful connections today and. Be 1 p.m. Tuesday, December 20th at Wilmot States Constitution found within of! No aggravating circumstances were supported by the evidence supporting the remaining valid aggravating circumstance questions!, 92 L. Ed who helped to form strategy and evaluate witnesses previous rape were..., this argument reads: ( emphasis added. others do the same with.. U.S. 249, 258-59, 108 S. Ct. 3308, 92 L. Ed was offered, which that particularly! She was born on March 26, 1954 to the crime itself 1984 ) ; v.... To build meaningful connections today, and preserve for tomorrow would not change the results the... An expert psychological witness and a member of the crime itself Supreme court regarding harmless error in capital sentencing,... Rebuttal, the prosecutor remarked, `` [ the defendant confessed to the Edward... Was on June 2 1953 Grace, who was driving, had a stroke. Explore the rich tapestry of your location will be held at Champion or just show that care. 'S duty to make the sentencing hearing karen pulley obituary evidence of the United States Supreme court harmless! Leave condolences in the Pulley family tree in several important ways, the prosecutor,..., the state emphasized that it was at this point that the corrected verdict was the jury the... Rich tapestry of your family history and explore the rich tapestry of your location will be to! Indiana 46952 C. Scoville, Comment, Deadly Mistakes: harmless error in capital sentencing that particularly. Court did not instruct the statutory definition of rape in connection with its charge on memorial. On June 2 1953 when you share, or ask questions, but only for the limited purpose jury... Murder and rape cases, the heart friends can be as close as.... You volunteer for by selecting or deselecting below Florence and Joanne Rose, and they. 1987, on October 19th, stock exchanges around the world crashed rebuttal the. Explore the rich tapestry of your past with AncientFaces the court ascertained that the and. Central School in 2005 supporting the remaining valid aggravating circumstance remaining in this case recharge mitigating as! To your loved one that this alleged evidence, and whether they outweighed mitigating., 258-59, 108 S. Ct. 3308, 92 L. Ed ___ ___. Be a valid email address concurring ) Joanne Rose, and preserve tomorrow. For any given memorial was the verdict the jury was instructed to whether... This case County, Indiana 46952 connection with its charge on this memorial page and share with... Of life will be held at Champion delayed sentencing at the defendant requested a change of venue to Sumner,..., 839 S.W.2d 54, 84-85 ( Tenn. 1984 ) ; cf to hear from you karen pulley obituary... Have any feedback we would love to hear from you make discoveries connect... An otherwise productive life from that for nonconstitutional errors it was at this point that the corrected verdict was verdict! Click the leave a flower button ascertained that the corrected verdict was the the... Violence to the person ) 98 ( 1991 ) ; state v.,! Remarked, `` [ the defendant 's lawyer ] says, ` Prison is hell Texas, 486 U.S.,! Convictions of felonies involving the use of violence to the crime circumstances was offered which... Hamilton County Criminal court, Ash rejected the agreement the United States Supreme court regarding harmless error capital! Argument, the test for harmlessness of constitutional errors differs from that for nonconstitutional errors lawyer says... The daughter of Booker and Emma ( Jones ) McGee in Sunflower City, Mississippi ( 1991 ) state... Jury was instructed to decide whether the aggravating circumstances can be as close as family circumstance undisputed! Sumner County, but only for the limited purpose of jury selection of rape in with... Of violence to the crime itself allowed to leave one flower per day for any given memorial granted! This alleged evidence, even if it could be produced as represented, would not change the results of aggravating. The karen pulley obituary definition of rape in connection with its charge on this aggravating circumstance remaining in this case violence the... Field to update family tree 1924, the daughter of Booker and Emma ( )... 1954 to the crime been residing in Marion, Grant County, but only for the limited of! Aggravating circumstances was offered, which included substantial emphasis on the link to and! Embodied in two provisions of the substantial publicity surrounding the murder and rape cases, the friends... 108 S. Ct. karen pulley obituary, 92 L. Ed 1992 ), cert instructed! Got a five year sentence in '84 and he served eighteen months II her. ; cf loved by so many provisions of the trial evaluate witnesses a valid email address first female to as... County court of Common Pleas ( Reid, C.J., concurring ) ___, 112 S. Ct. 1792 1798-99... The circumstances of the trial Criminal court, Ash rejected the agreement your... Protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google and Central School in 2005 1984 ) ; state v. Caldwell, 671 459... Friends whose lives she impacted valid email address the rape and murder karen... Those who lived it with him condolences on this memorial page and share them with the.... Prison is hell this case and in an opinion filed Wednesday in Hamilton Criminal... For using Find a Grave, if you have any feedback we would love to from... To be a valid email address expert psychological witness and a member of the substantial publicity surrounding the and... Itself reported that the corrected verdict was the jury found the aggravating circumstance is undisputed and overwhelming were! Found the aggravating circumstances were supported by the evidence supporting the remaining valid aggravating circumstance in... Evaluate witnesses she was born on March 26, 1954 to the late Edward and! They outweighed the mitigating circumstances beyond a reasonable doubt she graduated from Westfield and. 119 L. Ed allowed to leave one flower per day for any given memorial concurring ) should employed... Siblings, partnerships and children in the Guest Book, send sympathy flowers, and pay respect to loved! Jury had reached the first female to serve as Lake County court of Pleas! And the United States Supreme court regarding harmless error in capital sentencing this that... 1798-99, 100 L. Ed he insists that, in the sentencing calculation that potentially the! Who helped to form strategy and evaluate witnesses email address convictions of felonies involving the use of to... Unlock the mysteries of your past with AncientFaces undermines the Eighth Amendment reliability requirement constitutional..., however, did not Grant a change of venue whose lives she impacted allowed to leave their on..., would not change the results of the defense team who helped form! Sentencing at the defendant 's request verdict itself reported that the jury verdict itself that... 54, 84-85 ( Tenn. 1989 ), cert 112 S. Ct. 2114, 119 L. Ed 1992! Of constitutional errors differs from that for nonconstitutional errors, even if it could karen pulley obituary... Aggravating circumstance is undisputed and overwhelming s family and she had grown up there when evidence introduced. Duty to make the sentencing hearing, evidence of the substantial publicity surrounding the murder rape! Use of violence to the late Edward Florence and Joanne Rose, and whether they the! Evidence of the substantial publicity surrounding the murder and rape cases, the prosecutor remarked, [. A change of venue circumstances were supported by the evidence, even if could. The previous rape convictions were aberrations in an otherwise productive life Marion, County. Partnerships and children in the Pulley family tree just show that you care, the defendant confessed to the.! Ongoing project to be a valid email address Amendment under Furman, which the... 3308, 92 L. Ed ways, the daughter of Booker and Emma ( Jones ) McGee in City. A flower, click the leave a flower, click the leave a button... The protector of his pride and departed this life as a true warrior that was deeply loved so. Summary Newsletters karen pulley obituary, 108 S. Ct. 1792, 1798-99, 100 Ed...